Claim 8: Wood Rot
While renovating the deck of their recently purchased home, some home inspection clients discovered wood rot plaguing their back deck. As contractors removed the old granite countertops (presumably for an outdoor kitchen) to replace them, the deck broke, revealing the deteriorated main beams and support stringers.
Rather than continue with their deck expansion, the new homeowners paid to replace the wooden deck as it was. With the repairs completed, the inspection clients contacted one of their relatives, a lawyer, to draft a demand letter to their home inspector. In it, the family demanded that their home inspector pay for the labor and materials to replace the deck. They added an extra several hundred dollars to the bill for “inconvenience” and “loss of use” as well.
Why are wood rot claims so common?
Unlike most pest claims, wood-destroying insects like termites and carpenter ants do not create wood rot. Rather, saprophytic fungi feed on dead, organic matter (in this case, wood), which causes the wood to rot or decay.
There are two primary types of wood rot: wet and dry. Scotland-based building preservation company Richardson & Starling compares the two types of decay as follows:
- Needs higher moisture content to grow
- Wood likely to feel soft and spongy
- May appear white and stingy like a spider’s web due to mycelium (fungus) strands
- Often causes discoloration, such as darkening, of wood
- Decay remains in damp area and doesn’t spread
- Frequently accompanied by damp, musty smell
- Characterized by white mycelium (fungal) growth that has a cotton wool appearance, though it may have a yellow or gray tinge depending on its age
- Will cause wood and paint to crack and, when severe, to crumble
- Often spreads red spore dust reminiscent of rust
- Fungus may take on mushroom-like appearance when well established
- Decay can grow along and through the walls, spreading throughout the property
- Frequently accompanied by damp, musty smell
Wood rot is easy to conceal. In many of the wood rot claims we receive, the prior owners paint over the rot—intentionally or unintentionally—to prepare the property for sale. With the rot covered, inspectors miss the defect, and the real estate transaction goes through. Only after the seasons change, thus shifting moisture levels, does the paint peel, buckle or ripple to manifest the wood rot below.
What can inspectors do?
As with all claims prevention, it’s important to have a thorough pre-inspection agreement and inspection report—with lots of pictures of defect and non-defect areas. However, to avoid wood rot claims specifically, there are certain elements you should draw particular attention to during your inspection and in your inspection report.
Start with moisture-rich areas.
According to our claims team, wood rot claims occur most frequently in the natural wood and in areas subject to elevated moisture or areas that come into contact with the elements.
From plumbing problems to foundation cracks, moisture enters homes from infinite angles. Furthermore, from the roof to the ground floor, many properties have wood unprotected from the elements. However, typical moisture-rich areas subject to wood rot include the following:
- floor joists
- eaves or fascia boards
- door jams and thresholds
- window sills
- deck support posts
- roof penetrations and attics
- anything in direct contact with stonework, soil or exterior
Our claims team recommends paying special attention to these areas to better identify wood decay.
Call out concealed or inaccessible areas.
According to Section 13 of the ASHI Standard of Practice (SoP), inspections “are not required to identify and to report concealed conditions” (SoP, 13.1, B.2.a.). Nevertheless, veiled defects may still result in claims. To mitigate wood rot claims in concealed or inaccessible areas, and to make such claims more defensible, home inspectors should underscore potential problem spots in their reports.
Because sellers frequently conceal wood rot with paint, claims professionals recommend calling out freshly painted surfaces in your inspection reports.
Additionally, if you cannot access the entire crawlspace, attic or deck, you must say so in your report, and you should document any obstructions so that you can prove inaccessibility to stifle negligence allegations that could surface later. Depending on the amount of crawlspace you cannot inspect, you may consider recommending further evaluation by a third party.
Use all your senses.
While home inspections are primarily visual examinations, your other senses can assist in identifying wood rot. According to Clayton Somers of A Premier Home Inspection, LLC in Virginia, your sense of smell and touch can play an important role in wood rot recognition.
“There’s a certain smell—very earthy, like soil and mushrooms,” Somers said. Such a stale, damp odor often indicates that there’s poor ventilation, which can promote wood rot. “[If I then see something suspect,] that’s when I probe it. I usually use a screwdriver,” Somers said.
A pick test helps Somers determine both the type of rot and its severity. Mushy, spongy wood that yields to his prods, or wood that cracks and turns powdery when pressed both suggest wood decay.
Be specific regarding your findings.
When you do pinpoint signs of wood decay, describe your findings clearly. What type of wood rot have you discovered? And where did you find the decay? Somers and our claims team both agree that it’s essential to take detailed notes regarding the rot’s location to deter claims.
Depending on the wood rot’s severity, Somers recommends that clients contact a moisture specialist or a carpenter for further evaluation or repair. However, regardless of severity, our claims specialists discourage inspectors against minimizing their findings.
Protect yourself from claims
After establishing that the home has wood rot issues, it’s important to communicate your findings to the client well. Inspectors recommend emphasizing the limitations of an inspection and explaining your findings in terms the client can understand.
Even if you do everything right, you can still get a wood rot claim. Just take it from our home inspector in the example at the beginning of this article.
After reviewing the photographs that the claimants provided, our home inspector asserted that the deck joists were not in the same dilapidated condition six months prior when the inspection took place. During the inspection, the deck was too low to the ground to fully inspect. However, the issues were not visible either by viewing or walking on the deck, nor by viewing the deck from under the house at the time of inspection. Our claims team concluded that the joists were further damaged after they were exposed to the elements by the renovations and by weather changes.
Furthermore, the claimants supported the claims team’s position in their assertion that the deck broke at the time of the renovations. The deck did not break during the inspection and, therefore, the issues were not visible at that time.
Our claims team issued a strong denial of liability on the home inspector’s behalf. In it, the team argued that both the SoP and state regulations limit the inspection’s scope to readily observable conditions. Since sending the letter to the claimants, the home inspector has not received further demands.
It’s essential to carry errors and omissions insurance (E&O) for defense and payout help. Contact your InspectorPro broker or submit an application to receive a quote at no obligation.
Up next month: HVAC and A/C claims
This article is also available in the ASHI Reporter: May 2019 Edition as part of our monthly column Managing Risk. The column reviews the most common allegations in the industry and provides tips to make inspectors better equipped to prevent claims. You can see how the story appears in print on pages 6-7 below.